Lexan pitchers have a more porous surface than a glass mug. Particularly pitchers that have been in use for some time. Normally what takes place after dispensing is the CO2 is boiling out of the beer due to its reaction to the surface defects and the impurities / contamination they hold. This boiling results in a thick creamy froth but leaves behind flat beer.
Another issue is how they are cleaned. The detergent, disinfectant, brushes and other drink glassware cleaned in the same sink all have an impact on how friendly the glassware is to the beer.
Glass has always been preferably over lexan. Unfortunately, it is also very heavy.
Scott Zuhse, Instructor
Micro Matic Dispense Institute