[MrZ123]

Ok, so I managed to solve the problem on my own, here is what I did:

1.) I had placed a fan inside the fridge to circulate air. I removed it.

2.) I placed the fan instead behind the unit blowing on the small loop of coils to the right of the compressor (loop can be seen on the image above).

3.) I also used a hair dryer to make sure the entire door lining was sealed off when the door closed.

4.) Lastly I put new plumbers putty around where the pipe enters the fridge in the back.

Now the liquid temp inside is 37 degrees, air temp is 36 degrees! It may even still be getting colder which means I would have to turn the thermostat down!!

Thanks everyone for all of your help. Next step may be installing a blower.